Kids Do Well When They Can: Understanding Overwhelm Instead of Calling It Defiance

We had gone to the trampoline park.

Rae jumped her little heart out. She always did. Every ounce of her body went into it. By the time we climbed into my brother’s truck to head out for dinner, she was already done. I should have seen it.

But I didn’t.

In the truck it was me, my brother, my nephew, Thy, Channing, and Rae. We were talking about where to eat. Making plans. Moving fast from one thing to the next. Somewhere in that transition, Rae lost her ability to hold herself together.

Her mouth got sharp. Her tone had an edge that felt almost physical. Each comment landed in my chest like a small jab, especially with my brother sitting there, watching. I could feel my own body tighten. My jaw. My shoulders. That familiar surge of panic that says: Get this under control. Right now.

In that moment, it looked like bad behavior.

I remember thinking, Why can’t she just shut her mouth and stop being a problem?

I wondered why it was always Rae who took things one notch further and made everything harder. I felt that mix of frustration and helplessness as I watched her continue to escalate. I looked at how easily my brother handled his kid and felt the old, sinking thought rise up: I have no control over my child.

What I could not see yet was that this was not willful.

She had already given everything she had to the trampoline park. Her body was spent. Then we asked her to transition again. New setting. New expectations. New stimulation. No warning. No time to reset. She could not wind herself back down because she was already overwhelmed.

She was not choosing chaos.

She was not trying to be difficult.

She was out of capacity.

Looking back, the kinder choice would have been to skip dinner out altogether and take her straight home. Quiet. Rest. Recovery. Not another demand on a nervous system that was already maxed out.

But at the time, all I could see was behavior.

The shift did not come in one clean moment. It came quietly, through learning and unlearning. Through watching patterns repeat. Through trial and error. And then one sentence landed in me like cold water:

Kids do well when they can.

I did not have the tools yet. But suddenly I had a different lens.

Later, books and therapy gave language to what I was already beginning to see. What I learned was this: when Rae became overwhelmed, she did not know how to bring herself back down. Warnings about transitions helped. Clear communication helped. Explaining the social cues I once assumed were obvious helped. Giving her space to move helped. So did deep pressure, the kind that grounded her body when her nervous system was flooded.

Not because she was being difficult.

Because she was missing skills she had not learned yet.

There was no single moment where it suddenly all made sense. It was reframing her reactions over time. Paying attention. Experimenting. Letting go of the idea that control was the goal and replacing it with something harder and more honest: understanding.

If I could go back to that day in the truck, I would not see a rude child.

I would see a girl who had given everything she had to the day and had nothing left for the next demand.

And when I talk to my daughter now, I tell her the truth. Not as something distant or final, but as something living between us. I am sorry it took me so long to understand. I regret the ways she was misunderstood. The times she was corrected for overwhelm. The moments when I saw behavior instead of need.

I know I parent the boys better in some ways because of what I learned while raising her. They benefit from the growth that came through my mistakes. That does not erase what it cost her to be the one I learned on.

I will never be a perfect parent.

But I am no longer interested in who I think my children should be. I meet them where they are, even when where they are is loud, or messy, or too much for the room.

My daughter was not being difficult.

She was overwhelmed.

And learning the difference between those two things changed not just how I parent, but who I choose to be when my child is struggling.

I stopped trying to be the parent who controls behavior.

I became the parent who supports and monitors capacity.

Leave a comment